Some people have been known to
remove their rear pillar to make more space and a larger
access area. In my opinion, this is not a good idea.
Imagine
having a new home built & discovering that your
builder used a camp stove, sleeping bag & freeze
dried food in place of a structural component. You'd
probably want him/her admitted to the psychiatric
ward. |
It is argued that the gear will
take the place of the pillar. To understand why this
can not be effectively true, consider what all the pillar
does. Its job is more than retaining the basic shape
of the stern. The pillar keeps the hull and deck of
the kayak tight and up to a certain point, prevents
flexing. A mix of clothing, food, sleeping bag, etc
can not offer the same amount of integrity. Why is it
important to reduce flex? See for yourself in this simple
kayaker-approved scientifically satisfying test:
Grab a bottle of your favorite
brew and drink it. The glass bottle will represent
a kayak that has no flex. Now, grab an empty plastic
soda bottle. This bottle will represent a kayak that
flex’s. Wade in to the water and find a wedged
shape rock big enough not to easily move…basketball
sized or bigger. Find the point of the wedge on the
rock (upstream side) and rub
the glass bottle over this, back and forth, with enough
pressure to just scratch the glass. Notice that the
bottle simply slides off the rock. Now, do the same
with the empty plastic bottle. Watch carefully and
notice that when pressure is applied (analogous
to river current), the plastic wants to bend.
When this bending happens, the sliding is slowed and
with pressure still applied, the bottle’s momentum
will eventually stop (we've got a
pin now folks. Not good). At this time, the
ends of the bottle (kayak)
will be subjected to the full force of the currents.
And, if those currents are strong enough, the ends
will have no place to go except with the flow (if
the image hasn't come yet, think "wrap".
Think dire). The severity and speed of these
events depends on several factors. It should not be
assumed however that you'll simply be able to escape
the kayak at your convenience.
In summary, the flexier
a kayak is, the more likely it will bend when making
contact with a solid object. When this happens, the
kayak is far more prone to stick to that solid object
and if the current is strong enough, wrap itself around.
Furthermore, even if the gear could
provide equal amounts of rigidity to the pillar, the
kayak is still going to be weaker. Here’s why:
In conjunction with adding rigidity,
the pillar also acts as an internal beam of sorts.
However, a beam, whether it is in a building or kayak,
is only as good as its connection. Enter the modern
day kayak seat. All good kayaks today have a place
in the seat for the pillar to sit into, or in structural
engineering terms, a beam pocket. This acts as the
connection. Removing the pillar and putting gear in
its place is like cutting the beam in half that holds
the roof up on your house, at the connection, and
then hoping it doesn’t fall on your head.
While the latter example plays less
of a structural role in a kayak than the former, it
never the less plays a part in the over all integrity
of the boat.
Having a
pillar in place does not guarantee your boat to be wrap
proof, but removing it does guarantee it will be more
susceptible.
|